In a global research with over 600 CMOs and senior marketing decision makers, GfK has examined their perception of success factors driving effective marketing in their companies, broken down into three pillars of ”Impact”, ”Alignment” and ”Investment“. The survey responses form the basis for GfK’s new ”CMO Outlook Index", which shows that most senior marketing leaders feel there is significant potential for improvement in their organization. It also identifies what CMOs can do to achieve marketing excellence. The CMO Outlook Index will be tracked continuously, with the full report providing an even deeper analysis and recommendations being released in September.
The three central pillars of marketing effectiveness are: “Impact” (capability of team and demonstration of ROI), “Alignment” (leveraging the brand’s commercial value and purpose), and “Investment” (C-suite commitment to brand and marketing investment). GfK's global study shows that there is still a lot of room for progress. While 40 percent of the senior marketers say they have all necessary resources in at least one of the areas, only seven percent say they feel optimally equipped across all three of the pillars.
“It is relatively common for CMOs to have optimized either their marketing team’s ability or their company’s brand alignment or its brand investment. The huge drop-off comes when we look at who feels optimally positioned across all three areas. The findings from our CMO Outlook Index help marketing leaders to understand how their peers perceive marketing and where growth is needed,” comments Gonzalo Garcia Villanueva, Chief Marketing Officer at GfK.
Companies where marketing leaders see strong “Alignment” have more responsibilities assigned to marketing teams
The “Alignment” pillar relates to leveraging the brand’s commercial value and purpose: A quarter of all marketing decision-makers in the survey very strongly agree that their company has a clearly defined mission and purpose beyond commercial goals, and also that the brand contributes to the company's commercial success. In companies where the marketing leader feels they have a strong brand purpose, marketing typically has more influence: 81 percent of the marketing leaders in such companies include product development as a responsibility of Marketing (compared to 69 percent average for all respondents), and 78 percent say the same for pricing (compared to 67 percent average).
Budgeting for success: 60 percent of decision makers in the survey prioritize long-term brand building in marketing allocations
For the “Investment” pillar, GfK looked at the balance between long-term brand building and short-term sales growth, as well as the backing of CEOs and CFOs for investing in long-term brand strategies. 19 percent of marketing leaders in the survey consider themselves to be optimally positioned in both categories. Within this group, 60 percent say they spend at least 7 in 10 of their marketing dollars on long-term brand building, compared to 52 percent of all respondents. This level of long-term investment seems high, but likely captures budget beyond immediate media and production costs.
20 percent of the decision-makers believe they are ideally positioned regarding “Impact”: They have a strong team with all necessary skills and a good understanding of which activities, channels and marketing levers deliver the best ROI. Of these, 59 percent are extremely confident that their data, analytics, and insights systems will be able to answer the critical business questions of the future. This contrasts sharply with only 28 percent of the full set of respondents being able to make the same claim. “Impact” leaders are more likely than average to say they have mature capabilities in areas like customer segmentation, campaign optimization and extracting insights from data.
Index rating reveals critical differences by revenue and industry
The overall CMO Outlook Index is an average across all three pillars and takes the marketing frontrunners for each pillar into account: those who agree very strongly with the defining categories per pillar and who therefore feel most confident. This overall Index score currently stands at 21.
Looking more closely at company sizes, the index shows that marketers in companies with high annual revenues also consider themselves best positioned in terms of the success factors needed for effective marketing. For example, the overall index for marketing leaders in companies with annual revenues of less than 500 million US dollars is 12, compared to 28 for those in companies with annual revenue of more than 1 billion US dollars.
Interesting differences can also be observed across different industries: Utilities, Telecommunications, and Logistics companies have the lowest CMO Outlook Index score, standing at 17, while Technology and Durables as well as Financial and Professional Services companies have the highest score, each standing at 24. These even outrank typically strong industries like FMCG, Fashion & Lifestyle (index of 19), whose overall score is brought down by a low rating within marketing “Alignment”.
Comprehensive CMO Outlook Report to be released in September 2023
The CMO Outlook Index will soon be complemented by a comprehensive report from GfK that will provide even more in-depth information and analysis on the situation and challenges facing CMOs worldwide. It is designed to help marketing leaders worldwide address challenges and ensure marketing excellence in their companies. The CMO Outlook Report is expected to be published in September 2023.
For more information on the current CMO Outlook Index, click here.
Notes to editor/About the study
The CMO Outlook Survey is based on 633 interviews with a global sample of senior marketing leaders in businesses with either annual revenue over 50 million US dollars or more than 250 employees. Marketing leaders are defined as CMOs or Brand Heads, Directors or VPs of Marketing, Brand, Marketing Operations or Customer Experience.
The CMO Outlook Index is based on the CMO Outlook Survey and consists of the three pillars ”Impact”, “Alignment”, and “Investment”. Each marketing pillar score is based on the percentage of those " marketing leaders that very strongly agree to both of two key statements per pillar. The CMO Outlook Index is then calculated by taking an average of the three pillar scores. The key statements per pillar are:
Answer options ranged from “Do not agree” to “Very strongly agree” on a four-point scale.
Press contact: Corina Kirchner, T +49 911 395 4570, firstname.lastname@example.org
These are GfK’s global findings ahead of CES 2024.Read more
Environmental appeal ‘not enough’ to convert non-luxury buyers to EVsRead more
In the latest Green Gauge® study from GfK Consumer Life, more than half the U.S. population (53%) expressed serious concern for the environment, noting it should be a priority for everyone.Read more